John Broskie's Guide to Tube Circuit Analysis & Design

14 July 2009

Finally the Floodgates Open

Yes, it has been an embarrassingly long time since my last posting. I wish I could say that I had been off on a month-long cruise trip. The sad reality is that I have been crazy busy with PCBs, revising, creating, and, regrettably, correcting PCBs. Both mono Aikido PCBs have been revised and are in Rev D now. The boards now can more readily be used in the making of a Mosikdo hybrid power amplifier, as they now hold pads for bias diodes and bigger coupling capacitors. The 9-pin stereo Aikido board is also in Rev D now and it is narrower and taller; it also now holds solder pads for a simple RC power supply filter and bigger coupling capacitors.

New boards are now made and tested. A new octal All-in-One PCB joins its 9-pin brother. Two CCDA boards are also ready to go (a 9-pin and octal version), both of which are All-in-One designs that hold B+ and heater power supplies. And a new SRPP+ PCB also belongs to the All-in-One family. Another new addition is the Tetra All-in-One phono preamp, which uses only four tubes and its own high voltage and low-voltage power supplies. In addition, a new board that offers two channels of balanced-to-unbalanced convertors, i.e. two Broskie cathode followers, should prove useful for many who own equipment with XLR outputs but run unbalanced systems. Lots of new boards, in other words. In fact, there is even a solid-state stereo headphone amplifier PCB.

The PCB that needed correcting was from a previous batch of ten 9-pin All-in-One boards. I had screwed up a run of perfectly good boards, I am embarrassed to admit. I had laid out a huge panel that held about fifteen different PCBs on it, but before sending off to the production house, I decided that the 9-pin All-in-One board needed an extra solder pad for a transformer center-tap. I added the eyelet and I inadvertently pulled a trace into an existing pad, shorting a capacitor as a result. As far as I know, all ten boards have been located and I am sending out replacement boards right now.

On top of all this, I have been finishing all the user guides and I and my family made two trips to Colorado to scope out the state, seeing firsthand its potential as a future place to call home.

(I cannot see anything arresting California’s decline and, like several million other people, I do not want to be last one to leave the Golden-IOU state, as he gets stuck with the state's unpaid electric bill. Yes, we will miss the great weather, the gorgeous vistas, delicious ethnic food, and friends, but most of the features that made California a great place to live—good schools, low-crime, and middle-class suburban bliss—died long ago, alas. “The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people’s money,” said Margaret the Great—and she was right. Now if only the state of California could just print its own money... Wait a minute, that's what its IOUs are... Unfortunately, California leads the nation even as she runs straight towards the cliff's edge and I would prefer to be closer to the end of the line than the front.)

Speaking of jumping, before we jump into more PCB news, let's take a quick look at cross-coupled circuits.

 

Differential Cross-Coupled Circuits
We have touched on a few cross-coupled circuits in previous posts; the Blumlein "garter" circuit is one example, albeit a primarily DC cross-coupled circuit. The XPP amplifier also holds an “X” at its core. And the OTL computer amplifier from blog 19 back in 2004 held a cross-coupled arrangement. But what good is cross-coupling? Cross-coupling can come in handy.

I remember building a hybrid electrostatic headphone amplifier back in the late 1980s that ran out of steam. I used low-noise OpAmps and they could only swing +/-13V at their outputs, which was not enough to drive the output tubes to full output. I was sure that I had no options, as everything had been already assembled and I could not easily increase the OpAmp power supply rail voltage. Then the idea of cross-coupling came to me, which saved the day, as it effectively doubled the OpAmp voltage swing.

The Van Scoyoc circuit is the most famous example of a cross-coupled differential amplifier. This circuit was created back in 1948 and it gets rediscovered every few years.

I know why this circuit inspires. It is beautifully simple and symmetrical; in addition, it is DC coupled and it provides more gain that you would expect from a two-triode differential amplifier. So what’s not to like? To start with, the circuit, like most balanced circuits, works best with a balanced input signal, as it makes only a fair phase splitter when one input is grounded. Second, the circuit often develops more distortion than you might imagine from its symmetrical layout. The distortion results from the input cathode follower's having to drive a comparatively low-valued cathode resistor and another triode’s cathode and cathode resistor. Now although a cathode follower delivers a low output impedance, the load impedance cannot be as low as that impedance. In fact, the cathode follower would much prefer a load resistance that was just as big as we would use as a plate resistor in grounded-cathode amplifier, running the same triode and same B+ voltage and idle current—at least twice the plate resistance, in other words. Unfortunately, Rk is usually twenty times less than 2rp. The easy workaround is to use a negative power supply, which would allow for much greater cathode resistor values. Unfortunately, many tube-loving solder slingers hate negative power supplies, something about which most TCJers have no qualms.

Still, I can see how it could be a pain to add a negative power supply to an existing power amplifier that doesn’t hold one. So one workaround is to use dissimilar triodes; for example, the 12AU7/12AX7 combination is a particularly felicitous pairing.

 

Differential Cross-Coupled Amplifier
The following is an interesting circuit. As far as I know, it has no name; so, let's call it the “differential cross-coupled amplifier.” I built up such a circuit back in the late 1980s as a front-end in a Dynaco ST-70 I was rebuilding. How did it work? To be honest, the amplifier oscillated, but I had many trick circuit enhancements in place, including regulated power supplies and an elaborate remote feedback arrangement. I did however test the front-end in isolation and it worked gloriously well.

If the circuit does not appear obviously simple, try visualizing the circuit as being made up of two cathode-coupled amplifiers fed from a balanced input signal source.

Unlike the Van Scoyoc circuit, this circuit presents a lower input impedance due to the Miller effect capacitance. (This capacitance can be neutralized by cross-coupling small capacitors from plate to grids, but this is only for truly advanced practitioners.) The 1k cathode resistors, which each 12AX7 cathode sees, help linearize the triode and help iron out current draw imbalances due to triode mismatching. One great danger is cathode stripping at startup, when the cathodes are still cold and at -300V, while the grids are a 0V. The workaround is shown below. (I also added my signature PSRR enhancing technique at the final, bottom cathode resistor.)

So how well does this circuit perform compared with the Van Scoyoc circuit? The following table lists the results from SPICE with a balanced input signal of +/-0.1Vpk.

Van Scoyoc Vs Differential Cross-Coupled Amplifier
Circuit
Van Scoyoc DCCA
Gain
98.8
122.8
2nd Harmonic
-195dB
-195dB
3rd Harmonic
-88.3dB
-106.5dB
5th Harmonic
-161dB
-178.4dB
PSRR
-6dB
-40dB
Unbalanced Gain
49.6
61.3

As you can readily see, both circuits offer plenty of gain and low distortion, differential cross-coupled amplifier gain is higher and its distortion lower than the Van Scoyoc; nonetheless, they are both fairly close. Where the differential cross-coupled amplifier really shines is PSRR, but the Van Scoyoc circuit could receive the same Broskie treatment (if it used a negative power supply rail).

So, I advise that you add the differential cross-coupled amplifier to your tube circuit recipe book, as it could come in handy one day.

 

Still More Cross-Coupled Circuits
The following hybrid circuits are interesting because they invert the cross-coupling, building down, rather than up.

Simple hybrid cross-coupled amp with FETs and tubes.

The P–channel FETs limit the current flow through the triodes and should be tightly matched. The circuit's gain is limited by the 200-ohm drain resistors, but the circuit's PSRR is extremely good, as the FET's high drain impedance shield the 200-ohm resistors from B+ noise quite well. Now, let's take this circuit and cascade it. The resulting circuit is an electrostatic headphone amplifier. (A DC-coupled version could be designed, but I would be too intimidated by the high voltages to try.)

Hybrid ES headphone amp

Replacing the rare FET with a commonly available transistor is also doable. The diodes should be the small-signal types, such as the 1N4148, rather than the slow rectifier kind, such as the 1N4001.

Hybrid ES headphone amp

 

 

CCDA Once Again
I have built up 9-pin and octal CCDA PCBs into line stage amplifiers and I have been quite pleased by the results.

Stuffed 9-pin CCDA PCB
CCDA 9-Pin PCB

On the 9-pin board, I used a pair of 12AU7s and metal-film resistors and polypropylene coupling capacitors; on the octal, new Russian Tungsol 6SN7s and carbon-film resistors and PIO coupling capacitors. Both sound good, but different. The octal version offers a sweet easiness that belies its simplicity and low cost. I know that many long for this type of sound from their systems, as it produces an archetypal representation of what most consider being “tube sound,” but without the usually concomitant hum and power-supply noise.

Octal CCDA Stuffed PCB

Okay, since I made the CCDA PCBs quite some time ago, why haven’t I started selling them? The big problem that I faced, other than lack of time, was how to make universal kits. Unlike the Aikido, which delivers a perfect platform for tube rolling, as vastly different tubes can be swapped in and out of the board (6AQ8 or 6H30) without having to change the resistor values, the CCDA requires more care in selecting resistor values. For example, a CCDA line-stage amplifier that ran 6CG7s and used 20k plate resistors and 430-ohm cathode resistors could never accept a 6DJ8, 6H30Pi, or 6N1P, as the plate voltage would not center at B+/2, which the CCDA requires. But then, many are not pathological tube rollers; in fact, many do not own thousands of tubes, just a single pair.

The still-worrisome problem was, however, assuming the user stuck to one tube type, the daunting array of different possible B+ voltages. For example, that 6CG7-based line-stage amplifier might run a B+ voltage of only 140Vdc or as much as 300Vdc. Assuming an idle current of 7.5mA per triode, a huge array of plate and cathode resistors would be needed. Moreover, the plate resistor cannot be the little 1/2W devices that the Aikido freely uses, but big 2W or 3W power resistors, which are hard to find and expensive. Then it hit me, let the idle current move, but lock the plate and cathode resistor values.

A triode with a cathode and plate resistors acts like a resistor, not a perfect resistor, but a fairly good one. Here is a thought experiment: imagine that at the tube factory a resistor was soldered in place within the tube at its cathode and that the only pins, other than the two heater pins, were connected to the other end of the internal resistor and the plate. Now imagine that this odd design were given to a research scientist who set about measuring it. He would find that its current draw varied with applied voltage, much like a resistor, but with some sag in its current versus voltage plot.

6AS7 with 1300-ohm cathode resistor
6AS7 with 1300-ohm cathode resistor

6AS7 with 1300-ohm cathode resistor and ref line
Green trace is pure resistance

As the graph above reveals, a 6AS7 triode with a 1300-ohm cathode resistor behaves much like a 4k resistor. (By the way, note the much improved linearity over the plate curve lines, albeit at the cost of greatly increased plate resistance and reduced transconductance.) Adding a plate resistor also makes the triode behave more like a good resistor. The formula for the effective resistance is

      R = rp + Ra +(mu + 1)Rk.

 

 

 

The upshot is that if we chose plate and cathode resistors values to work at the middle of possible B+ voltages, the same resistors will still split the B+ voltage across a wide range of B+ voltages. The following graph was made from actually measuring the midpoint voltage of a 6DJ8 with a 10k plate resistor and a 205-ohm cathode resistor. The results were much better than I ever expected.

Plate voltage vs B+ voltagePlate voltage vs B+ voltage
Plate voltage of 6DJ8 [with 205-ohm cathode resistor and 10k plate resistor] vs B+ voltage

In other words, I do not have to supply huge number of plate and cathode resistors. I am still waiting for some resistors to arrive, but expect the CCDA to be available soon.

 

Next Time
I have run into my fingers limit again, so I will leave the rest for next time. In the mean time, the Aikido All-in-One Kits, the 9-pin, octal and 9-pin LSA/HPA, are available now.

 

//JRB

 

     

Aikido

E-mail from GlassWare customers:

Mr Broskie,

I bought an Aikido stereo linestage kit from you some days ago, and I received it just this Monday. I have a few things to say about it. Firstly, I'm extremely impressed at the quality of what I've been sent. In fact, this is the highest quality kit I've seen anywhere, of anything. I have no idea how you managed to fit all this stuff in under what I paid for it. Second, your shipping was lightning-quick. Just more satisfaction in the bag, there. I wish everyone did business like you.

Sean H.

  And

Hi John,

I received the Aikido PCB today - thank you for the first rate shipping
speed.

Wanted to let you know that this is simply the best PCB I have had in my hands, bar none. The quality is fabulous, and your documentation is superb. I know you do this because you love audio, but I think your price of $39 is a bit of a giveaway! I'm sure you could charge double and still have happy customers.

Looking forward to building the Aikido, will send some comments when I'm done!

Thank you, regards,
Gary.


9-Pin & Octal
PCBs & Kits

High-quality, double-sided, extra thick, 2-oz traces, plated-through holes, dual sets of resistor pads and pads for two coupling capacitors. Stereo and mono, octal and 9-pin printed circuit boards available.

Designed by John Broskie & Made in USA

Aikido PCBs for as little as $20.40

http://glass-ware.stores.yahoo.net/


Only $19.95
to keep track of your
tube and part collection

TCJ My-Stock DB

TCJ My-Stock DB helps you know just what you have, what it looks like, where it is, what it will be used for, and what it's worth. TCJ My-Stock DB helps you to keep track of your heap of electronic parts. More details.

Version 2 Improvements
   List all of your parts in one DB.
    Add part Images.
    One-click web searches for part information.
    Vertical and horizontal grids.*
    Create reports as PDFs.*
    Graphs added 2D/3D: pie & bar.*
    More powerful DB search.
    Help system added.
    Editable drop-down lists for location, projects,         brands, styles, vendors and more.

     *User definable

Download or CD ROM
Windows 95/98/Me/NT/2000/XP

For more information, please visit:

           www.glass-ware.com

 

 
www.tubecad.com           Copyright © 1999-2009 GlassWare           All Rights Reserved